Truce with Food: The Psychology of Emotional Eating and Your Relationship with Food
You've done Weight Watchers. Therapy. The functional medicine workup. You know more about nutrition than most people. And yet, you still can't make it stick. So now you're wondering if you're just the problem.
You are not the problem. The framework you needed—that integrates real, lasting change—just never showed up, so you keep blaming yourself instead.
Truce With Food® is a podcast for women in perimenopause and menopause who are exhausted from emotional eating, binge eating, overeating, and food noise taking up more space in their lives than they ever wanted. If you're eating when you're not hungry, can't figure out why what used to work no longer does, or just want a real conversation about your relationship with food and your body, you're in the right place.
Host Ali Shapiro is a holistic nutritionist, cancer survivor, and creator of the research-based Truce With Food® framework that’s also built on 19 years of real client results. She healed her own relationship with food and has spent nearly two decades helping other women do the same through honest conversations about food, psychology, physiology, and why showing up with a C+ effort gets you further than any plan that demands perfection ever will. And how the real work is to be counterculture and trust in satisfaction, not more discipline.
New episodes every other Wednesday.
Struggling with cravings, emotional eating, or feeling stuck with food? Find a conversation that meets you where you are. Explore the free Truce with Food Podcast Library by topic, or follow a curated listening Path: https://www.trucewithfood.com/library
Truce with Food: The Psychology of Emotional Eating and Your Relationship with Food
Why You Keep Feeling Like You’re Starting Over With Food (331)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
You finally understand what’s been driving your food struggles. You change how you eat, you feel better, maybe you even think, okay, I’ve got this now. Then months or years later, the cravings come back, your body changes, or you find yourself eating when you’re not hungry again. It can feel like all that progress disappeared and you’re somehow back at the beginning.
After more than 10 years of this podcast and 330 episodes, what I keep seeing is that you may not need another answer. You may already have the right information, just at the wrong point in your own change process. The blood sugar episode that feels life-changing when you’re first realizing your cravings aren’t a willpower problem may not help two years later when you already understand the physiology and what you’re wrestling with is why you still want cookies when you’re alone on a Thursday night. Same information, completely different need.
In this episode of Truce with Food, I explain why timing and sequencing matter so much when you’re changing your relationship with food, and why feeling like you’re starting over doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve lost your progress. I’m also introducing the new free Truce with Food podcast library, built from more than a decade of episodes and organized around the problem you’re actually trying to solve now, so you can find the right next conversation for where you are.
2:42 – Reflections on the good and bad of what happened during the summer season
8:06 – Disillusionment with what’s currently happening in the wellness world
11:19 – The pitfalls of relying heavily on AI for written content
19:28 – The inferior-superior cycle that keeps you ping-ponging between all-or-nothing thinking
23:09 – What I mean by “right information, wrong timing” and why the order of things really matters
31:00 – A newly organized, decade-in-the-making tool designed to guide you toward solutions based on your situation
35:20 – Demonstration of how the new podcast library works using three people as examples
45:54 – How to use the library (including curated paths, how to search, and how it links with your food quiz)
50:38 – Asking for two favors when you use the beta version of the podcast library
Mentioned In Why You Keep Feeling Like You’re Starting Over With Food
Truce with Food Podcast Library
Email: Ali@alishapiro.com
Episode 233: Quitting Alcohol and Managing Sugar Cravings with Laura McKowen | Books by Laura McKowen
Episode 330: How to Make Habits Stick When Your Life Is Unpredictable with Monica Packer
Episode 321: Why Intuitive Functional Medicine Works When Protocols Don’t with Erin Holt
Episode 267: Esther Blum Demystifies Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) for Perimenopause and Menopause Relief
Episode 266: Dr. Stacy Sims on How “Women Are Not Small Men” (especially at midlife & with exercise)
Episode 188: The 4 Weight Loss Willpower Myths Sabotaging Your Results
Body Story Series with Sas Petherick: Parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6
Find your Food Stage with Ali’s free assessment: Take the Food Stages assessment
Struggling with cravings, emotional eating, or feeling stuck with food? Find a conversation that meets you where you are. Explore the free Truce with Food Podcast Library by topic, or follow a curated listening Path: Explore the Podcast Library
Ali Shapiro: Welcome to Truce with Food, the podcast where we stop fighting food and start addressing the deeper story of what you suspect is going on, but can't put your finger on. Because the focus on food is a waste of your precious time, resources and life.
Essentially, food issues can be a physical issue, emotional issue, or a soul issue. And it's often all three. So starting over is what it feels like when often the right idea or right next idea for where you are, reaches you at the wrong time. And it's not that the idea was wrong. It's not that you're broken. It's a timing problem and a sequencing problem.
I'm your host, Alie Shapiro, an integrated health expert with a 19-year proven track record of client success. I'm a 33-year and counting cancer survivor and creator of the research-based Truce with Food framework that came out of my own personal experience, from recovering from cancer and yo-yo dieting. Because you name it, I had tried it. I also have a master's degree from the University of Pennsylvania. I'm affectionately called people's last best resort and a coach's coach, as people come to me, when they've tried everything and nothing's worked long term. This show is where we quiet the noise so we can go deep to get you the results you deserve.
This podcast is for informational purposes only and does not constitute personal, individual or medical advice.
Now onto the show. Well, hello, I'm recording this here in that august transition energy, before fall arrives. The humidity has broken here, in Pittsburgh, although I know we'll get another flash of heat probably in September, but I'm feeling the shorter days, the cooler air and I'm just like taking an exhale before it all begins. Fall is my favorite season, my birthday is October 1st, my business birthday is October 15th. Still can't believe it, this year it'll be 19 years since I left corporate and have been doing my Truce with Food work, building it, creating it, refining it over 19 years. Oh my goodness. S's birthday is October 28th. Oh, he's going to be seven. Seven feels so old. And fall weather is just the best. I kind of like the jeans and sweaters and sweatshirts.
But before we get there, I'm just reflecting a lot on the last season, which was summer for those of us in the Northern Hemisphere. And we have a huge bunch of listeners in the Southern Hemisphere. You were all in winter. So, what happened for you? What did it reveal? I think it's so good to just reflect and take a moment to pause and think, hey, what worked? What didn't work? What am I improving upon? So here, overall, we had a really great summer. I told Essa, we summered hard. One day we were at the pool for like nine hours and he went nonstop and I didn't understand how he wasn't running out of energy. And Carlos was like, he is powered by the sun. So we had lots of outdoor time. We did swimming. We did sports. I took Essa to his first McDonald's trip. He had never been and he had heard about it at school. So I took him there. And at the end he goes, I'd come back here just for the fries. We went on at lunchtime and it got really crowded when we were there. And he's like, there's so many people here. And I said, yeah, I said, a lot of people like the taste of their food. I said, also the food tends to be cheaper here. And he goes, wow, that's so nice of McDonald's to do that.
And I was like, I found myself turning into my dad. My dad always taught us about systems and structures behind the surface of things. And I said, well, Essa, actually our government has this thing called the Farm Bill. And the Farm Bill gives farmers subsidies to produce the cheapest crops, so that it makes this kind of food cheaper. And he was like, why do they do that? And I tried to explain it, but I hope more than anything, he just doesn't take anything at face value. So that was me just being, wow, I'm turning into my dad. We also, I don't know if any of you caught some of the World Cup action. Essa is really into soccer. He's also really freaking good at it. So our local soccer team here, who's, you know, they play in the American Soccer League. They had a big community party and we went down for USA versus Australia and USA won. So that was super fun. So we had a lot to nourish us this summer and get a lot of vitamin D. You know, there's this phrase in the fitness and weight loss and health space that, hey, summer bodies are built in winter. And I said to Essa, winter immunity is built in summer, meaning we got to get that sunlight. And boy, did we.
But also, you know, I think part of growing up is realizing there's always going to be hard stuff and good stuff. We really have to be able to feel and take in and savor the good stuff. There was a lot of hard stuff. I'm going to get emotional. Coffee, our dog, who I know many of you have been listening so long, you remember when I got him, but we had to put him down. He was, oh my God, I think he was around 14 or 15. We got him when he was about six and a half. We had him for about eight and a half years. And he was the first pet I ever had. I was always afraid of dogs. I'm also allergic on some level, but he was hypoallergenic and just the sweetest, sweetest dog. And like I said, it was just time. He still loved to eat, which was… He loved chicken. He was definitely a paleo guy, did not like anything else but protein. And he lost his sight, his hearing, so he was flinching even when we would just take him outside and his legs were hurting. And so we... Losing a pet is just so hard. And I think sometimes people minimize it, because it's not a human and it's still a relationship. It's still a really important relationship. So I don't think we should diminish how hard it is to lose a pet. And it was so much harder than I expected. We did have a vet come to our house and put him down. Really kind of expanded my idea of what love is, because he was definitely struggling and anxious a lot. Carlos and I were both sobbing and we're still so sad about it. And we gave him a great life. But still really sad about it. My dad, who is struggling with a chronic condition, those people in my group, sometimes I share more with them. So, I know a lot of you listen, you know what I'm talking about. But he had some really big setbacks this summer. So it's just really hard to see the people we love suffering. And that's all I'm going to say about that, because it's not my story to tell or share about.
Yeah. And then the world in general, obviously the geopolitical climate is, I don't know. I don't know what to say about it. I'm hoping that this is a breakdown that leads to something better. I'm not a Pollyanna and thinking that's automatically going to happen. And I know really good people doing really good stuff and really good organic ground up change that's happening that doesn't make social media, because it's not sensational. It's not polarizing and it's not divisive. And I see all the community stuff that we're involved with and people showing up and helping other people. So, I lean into that.
And also the wellness world, y'all, I thought it had hit rock bottom a couple years ago. And no, it turns out it could go even further. And again, I don't know everything and I know a lot. I'm pretty discerning. And when you are coming from a discerning place and you work with people and you know what actually works, right? And then you see people claiming all of this stuff and selling people stuff that is really a distraction. It's really disheartening. I hate seeing people being taken advantage of. And I'm just wondering, have we learned nothing? I was talking about… on my free workshop, about how Finn is in again and I have a very nuanced views on GLPs. I actually think I'm really excited about the autoimmune and chronic condition ways that they appear to be helping. And I think they can give a lot of people a nice assist with weight loss and feeling good in their body as the supplement, not the strategy.
But I see people just kind of this almost, I would call it a race to the bottom to be as thin as possible. And that is not healthy as we age. And I'm just like, have we not learned anything about diet culture, what thinness, what crash dieting, what rapid weight loss, what extreme weight loss does? And I don't know. And then people selling stuff. And I just think people are trying, you know, Essa plays baseball now. We're experimenting with two sports this season. We'll see how that goes. To use a baseball metaphor, I see people trying to major in the minors. Everyone's focusing on all these peptides, or creatine, or a certain supplement or, you know, a 30 day challenge. Again, sometimes all of this stuff is not bad in and of itself, but it's not the foundations. The foundations are still eating enough food, whole foods, mostly real food, still moving your body. It's still… sleep, oh my God, sleep is so important. It's about recovery, sunlight, your relationships, so freaking underrated and finding meaning in how you spend your time.
You know, the minors are the peptides, they're the red light masks, they're creatine, they're supplements, they're HRT, they're GLPs. And whatever else people are saying is going to solve everything. Like I can't believe what some of these people are claiming. And of course, if you major in the majors, which is the foundationals, the minors will work so much better for you. They can be like this beautiful assist. If I use my HRT example with my sleep, I had to totally change the way that I worked out, the way that I had to include walking, had to change my diet. Turns out I was eating pretty keto before going through menopause. I didn't mean to. I didn't really track my food, but I wasn't getting enough protein or carbs and I had to really work at all of that. And then the HRT was helpful. It helped me get over the hump. I'm in a snack before bed too. But that snack and HRT were the supplements. They weren't the main story. So I'm just, now again, if you're listening to this podcast, I am assuming you're probably more discerning than most people out there, but please for the love of your limited time, energy and pocketbook, let's remember to stay focused on common sense out here, okay.
And one last WTF hard update, I guess. I don't know if this is hard. This is a little bit of a lighter note, before we get to the rest of the episode and what I created for you. But one last thing that just feels like it's adding a level of chaos and overwhelm that we don't need that this summer is. I just, maybe now, I can just see it everywhere, because I'm really good at pattern recognition, but it is all the AI writing. Now they're AI, I'm not an all or nothing person. I'm all about discernment and flexible thinking. That's a big foundation and the crux of my own work is getting people out of all or nothing. And so I think there's a lot that AI can be great for, but the AI writing, I can just see it everywhere. And I don't use AI for creating content, because I think for me, how I define good content, is good thinking and stuff that really hasn't been pieced together before. I've even searched some of the own topics that I talk about with AI and they're not putting them together in the way that I've done. And I'm like, okay, that could be good, or still trying to change the narrative more. But it's because it's a very specific, I almost think AI is at the, a certain developmental mindset.
I think it's very black and white binary thinking, because it's always, it's not this, it's this. You're living inside of it instead of outside of it. Everything, the way that it's reasoning is either or and that's actually all or nothing. And that's actually part of what we have to evolve out of, not only for our food struggles, the way that we're solving the problems we're trying to solve right now. And so AI is rooted in the past, which it kind of ripped off all of humanity to get to this point. But that's not where tomorrow's solutions are going to come from. So I don't know. I get that content creators feel pressure to create more and more. After all, that's probably one of Western culture's top values, more, more, and more. We see it with more weight loss, more protein. That doesn't necessarily mean it's what's true and what works, because more isn't always better. But there's such a difference between accumulating knowledge, dispensing knowledge and then actually integrating it. Or the buzzword right now is embodying it. You can talk all you want. Everyone says, I was such a good parent until I became one. It doesn't mean there aren't good parents out there, but that development of parenthood changes you. I was this until I actually went through something. I get this content about maybe because I do think in integrative thinking, it's like I'm starting to get this content and all these people who were like super holistic. And then something that was outside of their control, a child getting sick or even them getting sick and then realizing, oh, I see, I was in this mindset of meritocracy that the more effort you put in, the more rewards. That is one of America's huge cultural conditionings is that you are going to be rewarded in proportion to how hard you work. And that's just not always true. Can't not work hard. But there's a lot more to it as we're seeing if we're paying attention. So going off on a tangent, but I'm just saying I don't know. I think that AI is, I don't have all the proof for this, but I think it's at a certain developmental stage and it's one that we have to grow out of and it's going to keep people in a lot of binary thinking.
I'm also recording this a few days after Dolly Parton passed. I had her Christmas album. Her and Kenny Rogers did a Christmas album. And I remember it was on TV and I thought they were married. And when I found out that they weren't, I was like crushed. We always laugh about that in my family. But I love Dolly Parton. My parents loved her. So we were always listening to her music. And I was thinking of just what a true leader she was in public and private ways. She wasn't bored on third base and thought she hit a triple like people who claim to be leaders right now. She was born into poverty and remained so empathetic to how hard it is to be in those circumstances. I mean, if you really want to know the number one factor in health, frankly, it's be rich. That's a whole other podcast. But my point is, leaders like her, I feel like they're all passing. And this is the nature of life, right? She was 80. As I get closer to 50, 80 feels younger and younger, but it's still old. And so it's the natural order of things.
But yet what I find so concerning and again, this is why I find AI and all the content creator concerning, because it's creating a certain mindset, a certain limited way of thinking, is that we don't seem to have people like the Dolly Partons of the world next in line to take her place. I think her, she was in my parents generation, I felt like they seemed to think more about other people. There was more of this collectivist value. Who wanted to give people a hand up instead of pulling the ladder up and out from those who need it most, which is happening politically right now with project 2025 and this current administration. It's just a fact they're taking out so many of the social support we had, for those of us who weren't born on third base. Anyhow, that's my last little rant.
One of the greatest gifts of going through my own Truce with Food and healing my relationship with food is, it forces you to grow capacity to hold so many feelings at once and being able to sort through them to take action on what's mine to do. Because yes, I don't eat when there's hard things like putting Coffee, our dog, down. And my dad's decline, because I've built a sense of emotional safety that is bigger than those hard feelings. But also because I can still feel the joy in the summer that we had and the work that I get to do here. Podcasting has been such a gift for me, which is part of the gift I'm giving back here that I'm going to get to in a minute. And the feelings of joy and contentment really resource me for the hard stuff. So a lot of my clients, you guys are the sensitive souls. You are the ones who care. You're the ones kind of helping to repair the world. And I know there can be a sense of guilt for feeling joy and happiness. And I want you to know that's what's going to sustain you. It's why you show up. It's what resources you and reminds you what you want to see live in the world. And how do you fight for that? How do you build and create that? And it reminds us why we want to contribute to our community, others. So I just want to mention that. It's holding the and, not the binary thinking of either I'm really happy and my happiness is taking away from others, because I'm not constantly doing everything, which women are the ones who are supposed to care and have to do everything. But you're allowed to be joyful and hold the hard stuff and use all of it as fuel to sustain you.
So I share this, because obviously I shared a personal update, but I know all of us are going through various versions of hard stuff. I have the privilege of a lifetime to be open to people's innermost lives, when we're working with food. So I know what all of you are going through on some of the deepest levels and it is not easy stuff. And I just want to encourage you to continue to take care of the basics, okay? Major in the majors, consistently, like solid nutrition, sunlight, movement, sleep and fulfilling relationships. And of course, if that's a struggle, the Truce With Food Podcast is here for you. Which brings me to something I've created for current listeners and hopefully your friends, who you'll share this new resource with and new people who find it. Like I said, I have been… I think I'm like a naturally melancholy, reflective person. I'm very happy, but I like to reflect as I share with my clients, like sad songs make me happy. And when my business birthday and my birthday and Essa's birthday are all coming up, it just makes me really reflect on time. And I've been doing this podcast now for over 10 years.
And if you've been listening for a while, or you've been working on your relationship with food for a while, which is probably the same thing, you've probably had the experience of feeling like you had to start over. Like the setbacks were so big. Or thinking you figured something out like sugar cravings. A lot of people like our sugar episodes only to have them reappear during menopause, when our hormones shift and our hormones control our satiety, controlling how satisfied, how full we feel from our food. Or that we have very stressful periods. That 40 to 60 year old range, where you're caring for parents, your own kids, trying to do what you can to show up for others and you're usually peaking your career. Or, you know, your kids are leaving home and you're like, what do I do? It's so disorienting and it's so intense. So we can have very stressful periods. Or if you're in a nothing phase, after an exhausting all phase, a lot of us try to get back to all, here in the fall, which is why I wanted to do this episode now, more on that later.
But in other words, you may have felt for a while that you found a solution, the tip, the book, the protocol, the podcast episode, the coach. It makes sense for a little and then you feel that little click of, oh, this is it. This is it. You do it for a while and then life happens and you're back where you were, sometimes further along, sometimes worse off and you're looking for the next thing. And what we tell ourselves about that is one of two things, when we're looking for that next thing is either, again, this either or mentality that AI is doubling down on. I'm uniquely broken. Nothing works for me. And underneath those thoughts, our stories actually generate our thoughts. That's why I don't even work at the level of thoughts. There's often a deeper story of I'm wrong. I'm broken and shame underneath these thoughts, when it comes to food in our body. Or the other side of the coin is this all or nothing thinking is, I already know all of this, I've heard it all and I'm still stuck. This is part of the same story of I'm wrong and broken, except it's the certainty, so that all or nothing is between total uncertainty and overwhelm. Or certainty and judgment, and above it all feeling that's trying to protect us from the feelings of shame, even though they end up landing us right back there. Psychology is very fascinating. It's so helpful once you know what's actually happening.
So we often spiral or ping pong between these same thoughts, because underneath they're all part of the same painful story. And I call this the inferior superior cycle, because that's what most people can recognize in the beginning of changing their relationship to food. I've talked about it on the show. You've probably lived it. I was caught it in myself for way too long. Anyhow, depending on what stage of change you are in, with your relationship to food, when people are in this cycle, most people reach for more information, a new plan, a reset, back to school as we're in fall energy, the new year in January, Monday. And so I want to offer some new choices to interrupt this unproductive, exhausting, and ultimately fruitless inferior or superior cycle. Notice how many food metaphors there are. It's almost as if nature was giving us clues about what our relationship to food means. If you're a client or have taken my group programs, you know how accurate that is, because you can x-ray and see what's happening with your own food patterns now. But anyways, I'm still amazed at how many food puns and metaphors are out here.
Most of you listening aren't short on information. You are a very smart, educated bunch, even if at times you worry that you aren't so smart, because you judge yourself as, I should be smart enough to figure this out, but I must not be. It's not a lack of information problem. So, if you've listened to this show for more than a few episodes, you have more information about blood sugar and cravings and emotional eating than most dietitians got in school. And that's not arrogance, that's just how much is here. Again, what I think is actually happening and I have watched this for 19 years with clients now, is that you've been taking the right information out of order and for someone else's stage of change slash development. So we always say you need to learn to walk before you can run, or babies need to learn to crawl before they walk. So there's a progression in development. There can be a progression in development with menopause that you couldn't have gotten to, until you have lived your 20s, 30s and 40s. And I'm going to be doing some more episodes on that, because another thing that I'm just so tired of is the pathologizing of menopause. It is crazy time and there's an inborn purpose that can help us reach our full potential, but that's not being talked about either. But anyways, so there's a progression in our development, just like with what menopause can be. Same with our own bodies and psyches. So there's an order to things, including the change process, which again, my expertise is in the psychology of change, particularly around food.
So let me explain what I mean by right information, wrong timing when it comes to food, health, and body information. So here's why order really matters. When you're at the very beginning of change, you're still gathering evidence that you're crazy, out of control eating, nighttime eating, binging, whatever you call it. In the beginning, if you found the show, you're still kind of, okay, Ali says this makes sense. What you're talking about, what is this… I don't know about that. So you're still trying to gather evidence that it's not just you being weak. So a conversation about the physiology of sugar cravings can be a revelation. Okay. Oh, this is how my body works. Cravings aren't weakness, they're symptoms I am malnourished, for example. By the way, it can take years to find a podcast like this or actually take action to trust in that, because ultimately being open to this idea that your body's actually making sense, that you aren't broken, this simple idea challenges the cultural belief that health is hard work and hard work is what gets rewarded.
Okay, we have a deep belief. I mentioned meritocracy, we have such a belief in America that all you need to do is work hard. Let me tell you you can't not work hard, but there's a lot more to it than just that and there could also be ease. You can't work hard all the time. That's a recipe for burnout. So it used to be, everyone thought health was beans, sprouts, cleanses and doing exercise you hate. Those of us Gen Xers and a little younger. Now wellness culture has turned wellbeing into a hustle. So now it's tracking all the things, always optimizing, buying so much shit. Oh my God. So much for your morning routine. It looks a little different. It looks like a little different trend, but underneath you're still having to work really hard to do a lot of the things, maybe you don't really want to be doing, to be like eating all the protein, fasting, to be rewarded with weight loss and the longest life.
But let's say you can start to hear the sanity of maybe your body is wise. Maybe you aren't broken, that you aren't wrong, but you just have the wrong approach. And now you've learned how to trust in nourishment and the power of balancing your blood sugar. Like my friend and colleague, Sass, who I did the Body Stories episodes with, did. This huge mindset shift around, oh, it's not about restriction, it's about nourishment. For my own clients realizing and balancing their blood sugar, the goal is actually to feel good and unlearn all the rules of what's supposed to be good. Instead of mentally checking off the box, what does it actually feel like to feel good in my body? Oh, so I shouldn't be skipping breakfast. Oh, sign of hunger is good. Oh, I should be eating carbs. I thought I was not supposed to eat carbs, or eat as little as possible. So as they come around to nourishment, in the work that we do together, it's like, oh, they figured out their blood sugar. That's a huge piece of the puzzle.
But if you hear that exact same episode a few months or years later, when you understand how your physical body works, when you already know its physiology, in this case, specifically blood sugar control and what you're actually wrestling with is why you still reach for cookies on a Thursday night when you're all alone, that episode does nothing for you. Or this can happen if you're on a low-dose GLP or a higher-dose GLP. And high and low doses are all relative to people. It's so unique. It's done enough to balance your blood sugar and now you're feeling really satisfied from your food. GLPs do a lot of things, but one of the main things they do is just help with blood sugar regulation, which supports satiety. So the same story can surface, because you're thinking about food, even though you aren't hungry. And then you think, this food thing will plague me no matter what. So then perhaps this is worse than nothing or neutrality, because if you don't know there's a deeper story that you're still running from, that you're wrong and uniquely broken, for example, not everyone has the same story, the same episode can make you feel like you're going backwards. I know this already. Why am I still here? This is the big thing that my work does, it reveals to people what they don't know they don't know.
So same episode, same information, completely different effect, depending on where you are in your level of understanding about why we struggle with food. Or as my clients who've worked with me in my program say, Oh, I go back and listen to certain episodes after having gone through Truce with Food. And I hear everything completely differently, because they're coming from a completely different place. They have learned to trust in satisfaction, not deprivation. So everything that's being said hits on a different level. They understand it in a different way. And that's the thing most people can't see, even other practitioners, because they're often only working on the physical level. That may be their expertise or only on the emotional level. I'm shocked at how many mental health people aren't clear on how blood sugar creates anxiety in some people. It's kind of like shocking, but not shocking anyways. And I'm not saying anxiety can be cured through food alone. Don't hear that when we're in black and white thinking or in stage one of change, we hear everything often in absolutes. I'm not saying that either. I'm just saying it can be a piece to the puzzle.
So essentially food issues can be a physical issue, emotional issue or a soul issue. And it's often all three. So starting over is what it feels like when often the right idea or right next idea for where you are reaches you at the wrong time. And it's not that the idea was wrong. It's not that you're broken. It's a timing problem and a sequencing problem. And so no amount of new information fixes a sequencing problem. It's like trying to teach a baby how to run. It's like, I just, I'm not there yet. Or it's like trying to reach back to my 30 year old self and saying, Ali, you don't need to work so hard and being like, what? But also I did need to work really hard at 30. I don't need to do that as much anymore. Sometimes I do, but not constantly. But with the current stage of life that I'm in, I can't, otherwise I don't sleep at night. And I'm trusting in that body's wisdom. So that's an example of the importance of sequencing. So we only want to do the right next step in the right order. That's what helps us make the changes we want to do.
So, enter my new podcast library. So it's not just any library. Okay. I love our library and librarians, right? Who can kind of really guide you. Here's what I did, or more accurately what Carlos, my husband did. God bless the men who really show up to support strong women. Like, ugh, I'm so grateful Essa gets to witness a new option for healthy masculinity. Hoping for this new generation where dads are so much more involved, or we have different types of families. I'm just hoping that that's really, you know, ground up change. But anyways, he's a genius, a tech genius, an editor and producer genius. But I digress. So he has come on board in the past couple of years to really help me with really telling the story of my work. And he builds everything you see on my website. And he's the one who said to me, I know you're really social and love people, but you can't keep answering that email one at a time. If you skip the intro, I talked about how I get emails every week from people asking me, like, what episodes would you recommend for perimenopause or sugar or alcohol craving?
So over the last couple of months, we went back through every single episode, all 327, 10 plus years. And we didn't organize them by title or by date. We organized them by what's the challenge you're currently working with, because that's when we go looking for answers. So sugar, the physiology, or if you're at a place where you suspect it's not really about food, you can ask about the four eating triggers, the protection patterns, essentially wherever you are in your process, because we all have to go through all four food stages, all the stages of change. We don't get to skip any of them. And these are all developmental. So they build on the next one, on the next milestone of where you are to have a truce with food. Or if you want to search who I was talking to, so some of our most popular episodes are with Laura McKowen, who is one of my favorite writers and no bullshitter personal development people. I don't know if she would identify as a personal development person, but she's the real deal. Or Erin Holt in our episode on intuitive functional medicine, or I mentioned my friend Sass, who we did six episodes on her weight loss journey. You can pull up everything I've ever done with them, in one click.
And then we did something I didn't know you could do, because honestly, I just don't have any patience with tech, but oh, does Carlos love tech. He was building communities, oh communities, he was building computers, when he was little. So every episode got read, all of it. And for each one, we pulled out the questions that actually answers, not the title again, but the questions. So when you, for example, might type, why am I eating when I'm not hungry? Or it attempts to find it. And this is kind of a little asterisk. This is a beta version, but it's already so useful. Carlos wanted me to wait, but I know that this fall energy is when people tend to return to their health routines. And I really want you all to have this. It's such an amazing resource. And it will only get better and better, in the months ahead. So again, it's going to essentially, what we say in the biz, meet you where you are, because that's the only place you can start from. I love all these people showing their progressions of a pull up and how long it takes, right? And how you got to start one way. Or in my group, we were talking about box jumps and how many of us, myself included, like we couldn't do a box jump at first. They're so important for your bones. Stacey Sims talked about them.
And it's like some of us... My one client, oh, I love her so much. She asked her trainer to hold her hand. At my gym, they put a weight underneath the box, so it wasn't so high to jump. So essentially, we have to meet ourselves where we are, or we're going to injure ourselves especially, or we're going to burn out, or we're not going to get what we actually need. There will be a link in the show notes to it, but if you want to check it out directly, it's trucewithfood.com/library. And it's totally free. It's on my website, not in an app. I don't want you to have to download anything or sign up for anything to use 10 years and counting of conversations. So I just want to show you how it works by telling you about three people.
So let's imagine there's three different listeners, because you all are so different, yet there's common themes. The first one, we have a lot of you who are sober. I work with so many of you and I just love it, because the person who stopped drinking, or changed their relationship to alcohol by cutting back, that is huge. The development, the change, the metamorphosis you had to go through, this is amazing to get to this point. And for a lot of my participants who are sober, or have changed their relationship to food, food was often their original issue and alcohol replaced that issue, or sugar especially has become an issue since becoming sober. So there's lots of sugar cravings going on. And often this listener is furious at herself, because she did the hard thing, she quit. And now it's just like the problem just moved. It's like, oh, am I going to have to give up more? No, no, there's so much waiting for you. I know you gain so much from sobriety too, but it can be hard in the beginning. And here's what I tell her, getting sober is hard and facing that challenge means you've developed more capacity, a stronger sense of being rooted in who you are. That is a sense of safety, a sense of emotional safety. And now those gummy bears you can't stop eating are pointing you to your next leap with that increased capacity and emotional intelligence you gain from getting sober.
And the same way I couldn't have taken on my own overworking addiction these past few years, without all the gifts and resilience that working through my own truce with food gave me, food is often the next transformation invitation after alcohol. Because now we have a tree with deeper roots. We can grow more into our full potential with more depth of a sense of self. So if you're turning to sugar in the same way, it's not really about the alcohol. It's not really about the food. And there's a curated path in the library exactly for you. It's called “Sober and Now It's Sugar”. And the first episode is, again, is with Laura McKowan, who she's one of my faves. She wrote “We Are the Luckiest” and “Push Off From Here”. I interviewed her for both books and another episode too. And where she talks about her own gummy bears, literally and why her eating disorder and her drinking came from the same exact pain. That's episode 233. So for example, if we get back to why order of operations matters here, if you listen to that first one before the physiology episodes, before the blood sugar stuff, you'll hear those blood sugar episodes completely different, because you stop thinking of the sugar as a new failure and start seeing it as a continuation of the same conversation you're already having with yourself. And when you open that episode in the library, underneath it, it says, if this hits home, listen next and it sequences the next one for you. You don't have to come back and search again. It does the discernment of order of operations for you. Super cool. Essentially the emotional labor. So you can save it for yourself, because if you listen to the last episode with Monica Packer, we know, women are doing a lot more of the emotional labor, like significantly, profoundly more.
Okay. The second path, nothing's worked since perimenopause. Or if you're like me, nothing's worked since I discovered I had just went through menopause and had no idea what was happening. I essentially built this one for myself. This is for the listener who, let's just say you're 46. Maybe you're going through it early like I did. Maybe you're going through it late. pre perimenopause. And maybe before then you could work out, work out, work out your eating for the results you wanted. Or maybe as progesterone has declined, you're realizing you don't tolerate as much anymore. And it's like, what is this? How this translates is, you know, you used to be able to tighten things up for a couple of weeks and it would work. And now it doesn't. The same things you did at 35 do nothing, or most likely they're backfiring, especially the all or nothing cycles of eating and exercise. You might be sleeping badly, making cravings even more intense, or they're just different. And your body is changing much more rapidly than in the past, because of the massive physiological changes that occur to insulin sensitivity and muscle mass. But you might not know that yet. You just feel really frustrated by the scale and what is happening. You don't feel at home in your body.
So you might be telling yourself, I've lost my discipline. My body is betraying me. And it's all downhill from here. Women become invisible. Because the cultural narrative of menopause and aging being this thing to fear instead of a deep development threshold, that takes all the energy that went into reproduction and now redirects that to your interests and gifts has fear and anxiety settling in. So this listener's path would be eating and perimenopause and beyond. And it starts with episode 258, where I walk through what actually changes hormonally and the psychological implications, like loss of estrogen means we lose the people-pleasing desire. And like I said about progesterone waning above, we lose our, hey, fine, it's all fine. Even if we never thought we were all fine, we're way less fine. And why conventional calorie cutting and intermittent fasting tend to backfire now. And by conventionally calorie cutting, I mean, eat as little calories as possible. And what turned my own hormonal health around after I went into menopause, early, at 43 and I was postpartum at the same time, do not recommend. Wow, did I have to dig myself out of a mind-body-soul hole, because I wasn't prepared, nor did I have the language for what I needed to stabilize me. So that's what that path is about. Save you the time and all the research, so you can get on it, because it took me years to piece that together, because there was not all the information there is now. And now half of it is bullshit. So you can trust in what I'm sharing.
So knowing what's happening, especially while you're in it, is half the challenge. So if you're here, I'd hit the perimenopause button and then sort by the most played, because tens of thousands of women have already voted on which of those episodes actually helped. So real women, people who are in the trenches, not an algorithm. So start with the ones they pick, because we have the wisest, brilliant women who listen to Truce With Food. As she, this listener, maybe it's your friend that I hope you'll share this resource with, or you listen, you will see nothing is wrong and it'll teach you how to trust the process. This includes future episodes. Like I said above, I want to talk about the opportunity and menopause and that it can be so much better on the other side, because it is easy to not know that, while you're in it. I know that for myself. I'll share some more vulnerability around my own stuff that I've only been recently able to name, because I was talking about it with other people, especially around my insomnia.
Okay. And our last and third listener example is you can't stay consistent. This is the one who's listened to everything. This is for you. Or if you're this imaginary listener that we had in mind, you who could probably teach all the ins and outs of nutrition and yet still falls off the wagon, or can't implement it enough. And for many people like this, you've decided that willpower, discipline, you're missing something out here or that it's just you, the problem. So that path that we created for you, or this listener is called why willpower isn't your problem. And the first episode is episode 188, the four willpower myths, where I brought on a client of mine, Justine, from our community here. In that one, there's a sample of what we discussed. Resisting the office candy all day and caving at four o'clock usually isn't a willpower gap. It's probably missing protein and or carbs at lunch problem. You might be reading the craving as something to fight or try to override, instead of a body signal. Ah, I'm malnourished. I'm undernourished. This listener could press client stories, a category on the library page. She doesn't need more of me at this point, if you know what to do and you've listened to so many of these episodes. At this point, you need to be emotionally opened up by other people's stories, not more facts or research. Because I know all of this and I still can't do it, it doesn't get solved by more of me. It gets solved by hearing some of your story and someone else's on the other side of where you are now.
Now, this is a side note, patriarchy conditions us, as women, to compare ourselves and judge other women, especially around our bodies, our health, our weight, our looks. So if you're in that inferior superior food challenge cycle, now, you might look at all the reasons the client stories are so different from you and this doesn't apply to you. Okay, great. Not everything is going to apply to everyone. And I'm going to challenge you to also listen for what you can relate to. You don't need to relate to one hundred percent of everything to get something out of someone's story. That's an impossible standard. But be open to what you can connect to, instead of comparing.
Okay, so I just went over three different people's starting point. These are three of the very real types of participants who come to my program. So I know these are also the types of episodes that we have, because most program participants have listened to the podcast for a while. But there are three completely different first episodes and if you swap them, if you gave the perimenopause episode to the one who quit drinking, she'd nod along and like nothing would change, because the immediate pain point she wants to solve is sugar. It doesn't mean she won't have to eventually get there to understand how her physiology is changing, but there's some things that people who are freshly, or a few years into sobriety, will get that someone who never had to go through that process, but is in perimenopause and that's the challenge they're struggling with right now would start at. And that's the whole point of the library, to meet you where you are, because that is the next right step. I also, again, to reiterate, this is in the beta phase, so it will be improved upon as we go from real user feedback. My program participants know experimenting is how we learn what we need to learn to get the results of what works. And I walk my dog! Now, it's a very quality start in foundation already and there will be iterations. Holding the and, it's not either or AI. Okay. Callback from top of the episode.
So how do you use the library? Practically, go to trucewithfood.com/library. We're also going to link in the show notes. If you're relatively new to Truce With Food, like you never knew it was called insatiable or I started out with my former client and friend Juliette as my co-host, press start here on that library page. There's three episodes in that order that will orient you and help all the other episodes make sense. You'll get so much more out of the episodes if you start with those foundations. I like to maximize my own efforts and yours too. I am an efficiency nut. I have to be as a business owner, a mom, a caretaker, all the things. A wife. Okay. If you know what you're dealing with, once you go to the library, you can type it the way you'd say it to a friend. I'm struggling with nighttime eating, or I eat when I'm bored, or I have all these sugar cravings after I quit drinking.
Now, if you want to wander, there's those of us who are like, oh, I know when I'm the most open, I find what I need. There are curated paths, five of them so far. Each one, though, is a sequence, it's not just a pile. It's very thoughtful. And there's also a most popular button if you just want the greatest hits, for example. And every episode opens right there on the library page. You press play and you'll get the four to five big takeaways, a line I'd underline what I think is really important as an expert in this field and the next episode to go to. And you never leave the page unless you want to. Sometimes I open up some of these pages and I'm just like, where am I? Not here. So you won't leave the page unless you want to open it on your own phone. And that's one tap too. If you've taken the find your food stage assessment, your results page now links a set picked for exactly where you are. This is so key because again, you hear things so differently. They mean different things essentially, depending on what stage you're in.
For example, if you're in stage one and you're still at that place where you think more information is what you need, you will get podcasts for that stage. But if you're in stage three and you're in that crux of actually working through the emotional edges of why you turn to food, you're now focused on a completely different problem than podcasts, where you have a completely different understanding of the problem. I love one of my consistency participants from last year was like, you know what is so stunning to me? Like we don't talk about food in this program, yet food progress is being made, because people who actually jump in the programs now understand the real issues so we can get working on those. But again, this is not like a moral judgment. If you're in stage one, you might hear this as a judgment, because we're very judgmental of ourselves and other people in that stage, because we're very much in people are right and wrong. There's a lot of rigidity there. It's not wrong. It's a stage of change. Okay. It's called like unconsciously unconscious. We don't know what we don't know yet. We all start there with whatever challenges we're having. So there's no judgment there. I really say that, but it's really hard to hear that tone, when you're in that stage. So I'm calling it out now. So those episodes, if you're in stage three, for example, those episodes are more for people who aren't problem or pain aware, but now relief and solution aware, right? If we're using marketing terms.
Okay. And every view has a copy link button. So you don't send your friend, my friend Ali has a podcast. Nobody cares about that. Let's be real. We're all busy. You send her the forum perimenopause episodes in order by most played. So I was talking to one of the moms, shout out to Sarah, who her daughter and Essa are in first grade together, but we were talking a little bit about her health and I sent her the HRT episode with Esther Blum and she loved it and was blown away by it. It really helped her with her health. And she's like, I sent this to like 10 of my friends, because nobody knows about this and they need to be talking about this. So now it would just be really easy for her to send that super helpful episode to 10 of her friends. And again, this is in beta, Carlos again, one in another month, but I can't wait, because it's back to school time. We're all focusing on our health again. And I just, I hate inefficiency so bad. It's something actually a problem. I've passed it on to Essa. He's like, yeah, that's a whole other episode. I'm already passing my issues on to my kid. But I just hate when people are working on the wrong problem at the wrong time. So if something's off a definition, a search that should have worked and it didn't, please tell me, that's the point of a beta. And that I'm asking two favors in a second. I'm really excited about the podcast library. It's going to make your life easier. It's going to be more helpful and it's going to make more use of all these great episodes. So two favors with this library and then I'll let you go.
First, please go to the library. Again, trucewithfood.com/library or the link is in the show notes and search for something real you want to learn about. If it comes up empty, will you email me? Ali@alishapiro.com with what you typed, like exactly what you typed, because we're going to use that to iterate the searching database. And when you do that, if we can't direct you to an episode, I'm going to make sure to make an episode about that. I am extroverted. I love the feedback, the conversation. I love teaching. I don't want to just be producing stuff that isn't necessary. So the library is going to keep growing. This podcast is not going anywhere. And every new episode goes in the week it comes out and the gaps you find become the shows I'm going to produce.
Second, and this is a bigger ask, because, well, you get the benefit of feeling like you've helped a small business independent creator, but it's a bigger benefit to me. And I don't ask much often here on the podcast. And this show, again, I have loved doing it and it's been a labor of love for 10 years. I've been approached about sponsorships, affiliates and ads a lot. And I've said no every time so far, because I mostly think a lot of what's out there isn't really worth it and is a distraction from what really moves the needle. Of course, this isn't always true and if there's ever a perfect match I'm really excited about, maybe I will. I don't know. But I'm not out there seeking it and there hasn't been one so far. This doesn't mean I don't take a few supplements here and there and maybe I can share if people are curious, or I use a few products myself. Again, it's not either/or and I don't do that stuff, because it distracts from the real work. And that's also why this free library is free instead of behind a paywall, because I deeply care.
So if this podcast has meant something to you, I'm going to ask you to leave a review wherever you listen and send this episode, this one, to one person, a friend or a coworker, you know, who might be struggling with perimenopause, or their weight in food, or a sober friend, who is struggling with sugar cravings. Or I know a lot of practitioners and coaches and therapists listen to this show. So many of you send me your clients. Thank you. We're a good team together. So if you have some patients, clients, group participants, can you please tell them about the library, the show? And that's how a show with no ad budget and just little old me, finds the people it's for. And I also want to thank so many of you who have already left reviews. We got a couple more this summer and it just means so much. I really cannot thank you enough. Us small indie shows, along with small business owners, we're really being stretched in so many ways right now. I could do a whole podcast episode about that, but I don't think it's really worth it. And your reviews give this show a boost for more people to find it and me, who appreciates the energy boost to keep on keeping on. We need each other.
Okay. I started with the emails I receive. I know you've covered this topic and I can't find it and I can answer it now in a very supportive order for what will best help you for where you are now. And before I close, as someone who has learned to be interdependent instead of fully independent, I really need to acknowledge my wonderfully talented, empathetic, kind husband Carlos. I couldn't have built this without him. I couldn't have grown my business and the way I have in the last two years without him. Carlos is my secret, not so secret content marketing weapon, but he does it with heart and soul, not with AI. So he puts his whole heart into it. So he also does this for other people too. So if you have a podcast, or a business that's sitting on years of content and nobody can really find it, you can check him out to do the same thing for you. It's contentwithcarlos.com. All right, the other website again that I've been talking about, trucewithfood.com/library. And if you are brand new here or relatively new, click the start here button with those three episodes and you might just hear everything else more richly and deeply and more helpfully. More helpfully? Okay.
All right, I will see you next episode. Until then, I'm wishing you a solid, rooted, strong start to your fall or spring. As the young kids these days say, go out there and touch some grass. Or as I would say, go just be a human being out in nature. Okay, happy listening.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Ideal Age
Liz Wolfe